Newly acquired Blue Jays’ ace R.A. Dickey is set to take the mound against the Indians on Opening Day. Go ahead and pencil in a loss for the Tribe.

Aside from the fact that Dickey is the defending NL Cy Young winner, he’s also a knuckleballer, which doesn’t bode well for the Tribe.

The Indians have lost their last seven games started by knuckleballers, including one against Dickey in 2010.

Most of this year’s team wasn’t around the last time the Indians faced a knuckleballer, so the losing streak isn’t more than a fun piece of trivia. But that doesn’t mean the Indians shouldn’t be concerned.

The real issue is that the Opening Day roster has minimal experience against knuckleballers. Only Bourn (mostly against Dickey) and Swisher (mostly against Wakefield) have any significant experience against the pitch.

And Bourn is the only Indian with any real success against the knuckleball. He’s a .321 career hitter against Dickey.

On the opposite end of the spectrum is Drew Stubbs, who has faced Dickey nine times and been retired via the strikeout in seven of those plate appearances.

Stubbs’ lack of success against Dickey is so overwhelming that it should probably land him a spot on the bench in the season opener. Francona could give Ryan Raburn, who is 3-10 in his career against knuckleballers, a spot start in right field.


  • Jeremy C says:

    You just have to laugh about Stubbs’s numbers or you just cry

  • Chris says:

    I think the best strategy is the one the Tribe used in their win over Felix Hernandez last year. Keep it close, make him throw a lot of pitches, get him out of the game, score runs off the bullpen. Or just master the art of hitting knuckleballs…

  • no1ever says:

    Plus it’s like an 82 mph knuckleball. A lot of lineups can’t hit that, esp when the fastball is 87.

    We either win 10-0 crushing him early or strikeout 15 times.

  • medfest says:

    The knuckler can screw up your swing for a week.
    Dickey throws the fastest knuckler I’ve seen,it’s more of a tumbler than a floating butterfly type.Joe Niekro is the only guy who even comes close to throwing it as hard as Dickey,at least in my memory.

  • Jeremy C says:

    And stubbs is in the lineup tonight! are you telling me that francona doesnt read IPL?

1 Trackback or Pingback